At no time in recent American history did the intersection of race,
place, poverty, and policy become more shamefully evident than during the
events surrounding Hurricane Katrina. The storm and the catastrophic flooding
exposed black suffering and government neglect to a shocked public and sent a
message to everyone who cares about building a just, prosperous nation: we must
change the counterproductive and dangerous way we have created and inhabit many
of our cities and regions, excluding people of color from opportunity.
That deep poverty exists, that it is concentrated primarily in black
and brown communities, that disinvestment of low-income neighborhoods of color
perpetuates disadvantage across generations was not news to the millions of
people living in such places. But the searing images of New Orleans – bodies
floating in the floodwaters, families stranded on rooftops, the sea of
desperate faces in the Superdome – jolted many Americans from the blind
complacency of their suburbs, their gentrified urban enclaves, and other
affluent communities where it was possible to tell yourself that ours is a land
of opportunity for all.
America was forced to recognize that, for Black America, far too
little has changed since the civil rights struggles of the 1960s. Despite antipoverty
efforts, our nation had not addressed the fundamental factors that keep people
poor. To lift people out of poverty and make good on the promise of opportunity
for all, we must honestly and authentically confront our nation’s deepest
fissure and most entrenched barrier to equity: race.
That learning has propelled the nation onto new terrain, where
policymakers, funders, advocates, and the public increasingly recognize race as
an overarching consideration that affects every aspect of society. This new
terrain isn’t always comfortable. Discussions of race add a layer of complexity
to policy and politics that many people are unaccustomed to, and uneasy about,
confronting directly. And sometimes the terrain is downright ugly—just ask
Shirley Sherrod.
Yet this new landscape offers tremendous opportunities for building
a nation that is more just, fair, and inclusive. It points the way toward
strategies that have the potential to transform distressed communities into
socially and economically vital places where all residents can participate and
prosper. By crafting solutions based on a clear understanding of the
connections among race, place, and poverty, we have a chance to get things
right.
Five years later, this essential lesson of Katrina is informing
action at all levels, from the federal government to the streets of New
Orleans. The Obama administration is spearheading bold, comprehensive,
place-based initiatives to increase opportunities available in vulnerable
communities and achieve broad improvements in the well-being of residents.
For example, the Sustainable Communities initiative will help
regional consortia lay out a smarter, more environmentally sound, and more
inclusive future for entire regions. The Promise Neighborhoods and Choice
Neighborhoods initiatives leverage and combine the resources of programs that
have historically operated in distinct spheres – neighborhoods and education in
the case of Promise, and housing, transportation, economic development, and
education in Choice – to break the cycle of generational poverty.
By targeting high-poverty areas, these programs zero in on
communities of color. And by focusing simultaneously on people and the places
they live, these programs avoid the past mistakes of antipoverty efforts that
invested either in physical makeovers of neighborhoods while leaving residents
high and dry, or in services to individuals without addressing the
environmental factors crucial for sustained advancement.
These federal initiatives hold real hope for changing the life
trajectory of poor children of color for generations to come. They must be
fully funded.
A growing number of foundations, too, are directing resources at the
nexus of race, place, and poverty. As a starting point, they are grappling with
long-unspoken questions about skin color and ethnicity. What roles have bias
and racism played in the disinvestment of communities? In the inequitable
delivery of services? In the widely disparate outcomes in health and education,
two areas of longstanding concern to philanthropy?
The Open Society Institute’s Campaign for Black Male Achievement,
for example, addresses the exclusion of black men and boys from social,
educational, and political life. The Kellogg Foundation recently launched a
five-year, $75 million initiative to improve outcomes for vulnerable children
and their families by promoting racial healing and eliminating barriers to
opportunities – and received nearly 1,000 proposals for funding.
A similar shift is happening at many think tanks, community
organizations, and advocacy organizations dedicated to fighting poverty. Race
was for so long an untouchable consideration. At last people are engaging the
subject forthrightly. Katrina jolted even veterans of antipoverty struggles
into recognizing that African American poverty is a special problem, rooted in
a history of racism older than the country itself and supported by inequitable
structures and systems that undergird communities like the steel skeleton of a
skyscraper.
But those structures and systems can change. Just as Katrina opened
the nation’s eyes to African American suffering, bottom-up recovery efforts are
showing us the resilience and enormous potential of low-income communities. The
best of the recovery work has capitalized on the rich cultural and aesthetic
assets of New Orleans and the Gulf region. Residents, advocates, volunteers,
and faith organizations have kept the spotlight on the disparate impact of the
disaster on African Americans and the dire needs yet to be addressed.
The work has gone beyond a single fix – for instance, housing
restoration, critical as that has been – to press for the services and
opportunities that make a place the kind of community we all want to live in—a
community with high-quality schools, grocery stores, transportation, health
clinics, and parks. Innovative projects are emerging as models of equitable
development. In the process, residents have discovered their voice, their
imagination, their power.
The rest of the country needs to pay attention to the lessons from
the Gulf region today, as we did five years ago.
Angela Glover Blackwell is the founder and CEO of PolicyLink,
a national research and action institute advancing economic and social equity.